Proof.
Observe that (2) and (3) are equivalent by definition.
Assume (1), let $N_1, N_2$ be $S$-modules, and let $\varphi : N_1 \to N_2$ be an $R$-linear map. For any $x \in N_1$ consider the map $S \otimes _ R S \to N_2$ defined by the rule $g \otimes g' \mapsto g\varphi (g'x)$. Since both maps $S \to S \otimes _ R S$ are isomorphisms (Lemma 10.107.1), we conclude that $g \varphi (g'x) = gg'\varphi (x) = \varphi (gg' x)$. Thus $\varphi $ is $S$-linear.
Assume (2). Let $N_1 = S \otimes _ R S$ viewed as an $S$-module via the left $S$-module action and let $N_2 = S \otimes _ R S$ with the right $S$-module action. Since $N_1 = N_2$ as $R$-modules, by (2) we see that the two $S$-module structures on $S \otimes _ R S$ coincide. This implies (1) by Lemma 10.107.1.
$\square$
Comments (2)
Comment #11029 by Kiran Kedlaya on
Comment #11198 by Stacks project on