Lemma 10.58.1. Let $S$ be a graded ring. A set of homogeneous elements $f_ i \in S_{+}$ generates $S$ as an algebra over $S_0$ if and only if they generate $S_{+}$ as an ideal of $S$.

## 10.58 Noetherian graded rings

A bit of theory on Noetherian graded rings including some material on Hilbert polynomials.

**Proof.**
If the $f_ i$ generate $S$ as an algebra over $S_0$ then every element in $S_{+}$ is a polynomial without constant term in the $f_ i$ and hence $S_{+}$ is generated by the $f_ i$ as an ideal. Conversely, suppose that $S_{+} = \sum Sf_ i$. We will prove that any element $f$ of $S$ can be written as a polynomial in the $f_ i$ with coefficients in $S_0$. It suffices to do this for homogeneous elements. Say $f$ has degree $d$. Then we may perform induction on $d$. The case $d = 0$ is immediate. If $d > 0$ then $f \in S_{+}$ hence we can write $f = \sum g_ i f_ i$ for some $g_ i \in S$. As $S$ is graded we can replace $g_ i$ by its homogeneous component of degree $d - \deg (f_ i)$. By induction we see that each $g_ i$ is a polynomial in the $f_ i$ and we win.
$\square$

Lemma 10.58.2. A graded ring $S$ is Noetherian if and only if $S_0$ is Noetherian and $S_{+}$ is finitely generated as an ideal of $S$.

**Proof.**
It is clear that if $S$ is Noetherian then $S_0 = S/S_{+}$ is Noetherian and $S_{+}$ is finitely generated. Conversely, assume $S_0$ is Noetherian and $S_{+}$ finitely generated as an ideal of $S$. Pick generators $S_{+} = (f_1, \ldots , f_ n)$. By decomposing the $f_ i$ into homogeneous pieces we may assume each $f_ i$ is homogeneous. By Lemma 10.58.1 we see that $S_0[X_1, \ldots X_ n] \to S$ sending $X_ i$ to $f_ i$ is surjective. Thus $S$ is Noetherian by Lemma 10.31.1.
$\square$

Definition 10.58.3. Let $A$ be an abelian group. We say that a function $f : n \mapsto f(n) \in A$ defined for all sufficient large integers $n$ is a *numerical polynomial* if there exists $r \geq 0$, elements $a_0, \ldots , a_ r\in A$ such that

for all $n \gg 0$.

The reason for using the binomial coefficients is the elementary fact that any polynomial $P \in \mathbf{Q}[T]$ all of whose values at integer points are integers, is equal to a sum $P(T) = \sum a_ i \binom {T}{i}$ with $a_ i \in \mathbf{Z}$. Note that in particular the expressions $\binom {T + 1}{i + 1}$ are of this form.

Lemma 10.58.4. If $A \to A'$ is a homomorphism of abelian groups and if $f : n \mapsto f(n) \in A$ is a numerical polynomial, then so is the composition.

**Proof.**
This is immediate from the definitions.
$\square$

Lemma 10.58.5. Suppose that $f: n \mapsto f(n) \in A$ is defined for all $n$ sufficiently large and suppose that $n \mapsto f(n) - f(n-1)$ is a numerical polynomial. Then $f$ is a numerical polynomial.

**Proof.**
Let $f(n) - f(n-1) = \sum \nolimits _{i = 0}^ r \binom {n}{i} a_ i$ for all $n \gg 0$. Set $g(n) = f(n) - \sum \nolimits _{i = 0}^ r \binom {n + 1}{i + 1} a_ i$. Then $g(n) - g(n-1) = 0$ for all $n \gg 0$. Hence $g$ is eventually constant, say equal to $a_{-1}$. We leave it to the reader to show that $a_{-1} + \sum \nolimits _{i = 0}^ r \binom {n + 1}{i + 1} a_ i$ has the required shape (see remark above the lemma).
$\square$

Lemma 10.58.6. If $M$ is a finitely generated graded $S$-module, and if $S$ is finitely generated over $S_0$, then each $M_ n$ is a finite $S_0$-module.

**Proof.**
Suppose the generators of $M$ are $m_ i$ and the generators of $S$ are $f_ i$. By taking homogeneous components we may assume that the $m_ i$ and the $f_ i$ are homogeneous and we may assume $f_ i \in S_{+}$. In this case it is clear that each $M_ n$ is generated over $S_0$ by the “monomials” $\prod f_ i^{e_ i} m_ j$ whose degree is $n$.
$\square$

Proposition 10.58.7. Suppose that $S$ is a Noetherian graded ring and $M$ a finite graded $S$-module. Consider the function

see Lemma 10.58.6. If $S_{+}$ is generated by elements of degree $1$, then this function is a numerical polynomial.

**Proof.**
We prove this by induction on the minimal number of generators of $S_1$. If this number is $0$, then $M_ n = 0$ for all $n \gg 0$ and the result holds. To prove the induction step, let $x\in S_1$ be one of a minimal set of generators, such that the induction hypothesis applies to the graded ring $S/(x)$.

First we show the result holds if $x$ is nilpotent on $M$. This we do by induction on the minimal integer $r$ such that $x^ r M = 0$. If $r = 1$, then $M$ is a module over $S/xS$ and the result holds (by the other induction hypothesis). If $r > 1$, then we can find a short exact sequence $0 \to M' \to M \to M'' \to 0$ such that the integers $r', r''$ are strictly smaller than $r$. Thus we know the result for $M''$ and $M'$. Hence we get the result for $M$ because of the relation $ [M_ d] = [M'_ d] + [M''_ d] $ in $K'_0(S_0)$.

If $x$ is not nilpotent on $M$, let $M' \subset M$ be the largest submodule on which $x$ is nilpotent. Consider the exact sequence $0 \to M' \to M \to M/M' \to 0$ we see again it suffices to prove the result for $M/M'$. In other words we may assume that multiplication by $x$ is injective.

Let $\overline{M} = M/xM$. Note that the map $x : M \to M$ is *not* a map of graded $S$-modules, since it does not map $M_ d$ into $M_ d$. Namely, for each $d$ we have the following short exact sequence

This proves that $[M_{d + 1}] - [M_ d] = [\overline{M}_{d + 1}]$. Hence we win by Lemma 10.58.5. $\square$

Remark 10.58.8. If $S$ is still Noetherian but $S$ is not generated in degree $1$, then the function associated to a graded $S$-module is a periodic polynomial (i.e., it is a numerical polynomial on the congruence classes of integers modulo $n$ for some $n$).

Example 10.58.9. Suppose that $S = k[X_1, \ldots , X_ d]$. By Example 10.55.2 we may identify $K_0(k) = K'_0(k) = \mathbf{Z}$. Hence any finitely generated graded $k[X_1, \ldots , X_ d]$-module gives rise to a numerical polynomial $n \mapsto \dim _ k(M_ n)$.

Lemma 10.58.10. Let $k$ be a field. Suppose that $I \subset k[X_1, \ldots , X_ d]$ is a nonzero graded ideal. Let $M = k[X_1, \ldots , X_ d]/I$. Then the numerical polynomial $n \mapsto \dim _ k(M_ n)$ (see Example 10.58.9) has degree $ < d - 1$ (or is zero if $d = 1$).

**Proof.**
The numerical polynomial associated to the graded module $k[X_1, \ldots , X_ d]$ is $n \mapsto \binom {n - 1 + d}{d - 1}$. For any nonzero homogeneous $f \in I$ of degree $e$ and any degree $n >> e$ we have $I_ n \supset f \cdot k[X_1, \ldots , X_ d]_{n-e}$ and hence $\dim _ k(I_ n) \geq \binom {n - e - 1 + d}{d - 1}$. Hence $\dim _ k(M_ n) \leq \binom {n - 1 + d}{d - 1} - \binom {n - e - 1 + d}{d - 1}$. We win because the last expression has degree $ < d - 1$ (or is zero if $d = 1$).
$\square$

## Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked.

In your comment you can use Markdown and LaTeX style mathematics (enclose it like `$\pi$`

). A preview option is available if you wish to see how it works out (just click on the eye in the toolbar).

Unfortunately JavaScript is disabled in your browser, so the comment preview function will not work.

All contributions are licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License.

## Comments (5)

Comment #339 by stul on

Comment #340 by Johan on

Comment #678 by Keenan Kidwell on

Comment #2238 by Richard on

Comment #2273 by Johan on