## 10.145 Conormal modules and universal thickenings

It turns out that one can define the first infinitesimal neighbourhood not just for a closed immersion of schemes, but already for any formally unramified morphism. This is based on the following algebraic fact.

Lemma 10.145.1. Let $R \to S$ be a formally unramified ring map. There exists a surjection of $R$-algebras $S' \to S$ whose kernel is an ideal of square zero with the following universal property: Given any commutative diagram

\[ \xymatrix{ S \ar[r]_ a & A/I \\ R \ar[r]^ b \ar[u] & A \ar[u] } \]

where $I \subset A$ is an ideal of square zero, there is a unique $R$-algebra map $a' : S' \to A$ such that $S' \to A \to A/I$ is equal to $S' \to S \to A/I$.

**Proof.**
Choose a set of generators $z_ i \in S$, $i \in I$ for $S$ as an $R$-algebra. Let $P = R[\{ x_ i\} _{i \in I}]$ denote the polynomial ring on generators $x_ i$, $i \in I$. Consider the $R$-algebra map $P \to S$ which maps $x_ i$ to $z_ i$. Let $J = \mathop{\mathrm{Ker}}(P \to S)$. Consider the map

\[ \text{d} : J/J^2 \longrightarrow \Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P S \]

see Lemma 10.130.9. This is surjective since $\Omega _{S/R} = 0$ by assumption, see Lemma 10.144.2. Note that $\Omega _{P/R}$ is free on $\text{d}x_ i$, and hence the module $\Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P S$ is free over $S$. Thus we may choose a splitting of the surjection above and write

\[ J/J^2 = K \oplus \Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P S \]

Let $J^2 \subset J' \subset J$ be the ideal of $P$ such that $J'/J^2$ is the second summand in the decomposition above. Set $S' = P/J'$. We obtain a short exact sequence

\[ 0 \to J/J' \to S' \to S \to 0 \]

and we see that $J/J' \cong K$ is a square zero ideal in $S'$. Hence

\[ \xymatrix{ S \ar[r]_1 & S \\ R \ar[r] \ar[u] & S' \ar[u] } \]

is a diagram as above. In fact we claim that this is an initial object in the category of diagrams. Namely, let $(I \subset A, a, b)$ be an arbitrary diagram. We may choose an $R$-algebra map $\beta : P \to A$ such that

\[ \xymatrix{ S \ar[r]_1 & S \ar[r]_ a & A/I \\ R \ar[r] \ar@/_/[rr]_ b \ar[u] & P \ar[u] \ar[r]^\beta & A \ar[u] } \]

is commutative. Now it may not be the case that $\beta (J') = 0$, in other words it may not be true that $\beta $ factors through $S' = P/J'$. But what is clear is that $\beta (J') \subset I$ and since $\beta (J) \subset I$ and $I^2 = 0$ we have $\beta (J^2) = 0$. Thus the “obstruction” to finding a morphism from $(J/J' \subset S', 1, R \to S')$ to $(I \subset A, a, b)$ is the corresponding $S$-linear map $\overline{\beta } : J'/J^2 \to I$. The choice in picking $\beta $ lies in the choice of $\beta (x_ i)$. A different choice of $\beta $, say $\beta '$, is gotten by taking $\beta '(x_ i) = \beta (x_ i) + \delta _ i$ with $\delta _ i \in I$. In this case, for $g \in J'$, we obtain

\[ \beta '(g) = \beta (g) + \sum \nolimits _ i \delta _ i \frac{\partial g}{\partial x_ i}. \]

Since the map $\text{d}|_{J'/J^2} : J'/J^2 \to \Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P S$ given by $g \mapsto \frac{\partial g}{\partial x_ i}\text{d}x_ i$ is an isomorphism by construction, we see that there is a unique choice of $\delta _ i \in I$ such that $\beta '(g) = 0$ for all $g \in J'$. (Namely, $\delta _ i$ is $-\overline{\beta }(g)$ where $g \in J'/J^2$ is the unique element with $\frac{\partial g}{\partial x_ j} = 1$ if $i = j$ and $0$ else.) The uniqueness of the solution implies the uniqueness required in the lemma.
$\square$

In the situation of Lemma 10.145.1 the $R$-algebra map $S' \to S$ is unique up to unique isomorphism.

Definition 10.145.2. Let $R \to S$ be a formally unramified ring map.

The *universal first order thickening* of $S$ over $R$ is the surjection of $R$-algebras $S' \to S$ of Lemma 10.145.1.

The *conormal module* of $R \to S$ is the kernel $I$ of the universal first order thickening $S' \to S$, seen as an $S$-module.

We often denote the conormal module *$C_{S/R}$* in this situation.

Lemma 10.145.3. Let $I \subset R$ be an ideal of a ring. The universal first order thickening of $R/I$ over $R$ is the surjection $R/I^2 \to R/I$. The conormal module of $R/I$ over $R$ is $C_{(R/I)/R} = I/I^2$.

**Proof.**
Omitted.
$\square$

Lemma 10.145.4. Let $A \to B$ be a formally unramified ring map. Let $\varphi : B' \to B$ be the universal first order thickening of $B$ over $A$.

Let $S \subset A$ be a multiplicative subset. Then $S^{-1}B' \to S^{-1}B$ is the universal first order thickening of $S^{-1}B$ over $S^{-1}A$. In particular $S^{-1}C_{B/A} = C_{S^{-1}B/S^{-1}A}$.

Let $S \subset B$ be a multiplicative subset. Then $S' = \varphi ^{-1}(S)$ is a multiplicative subset in $B'$ and $(S')^{-1}B' \to S^{-1}B$ is the universal first order thickening of $S^{-1}B$ over $A$. In particular $S^{-1}C_{B/A} = C_{S^{-1}B/A}$.

Note that the lemma makes sense by Lemma 10.144.4.

**Proof.**
With notation and assumptions as in (1). Let $(S^{-1}B)' \to S^{-1}B$ be the universal first order thickening of $S^{-1}B$ over $S^{-1}A$. Note that $S^{-1}B' \to S^{-1}B$ is a surjection of $S^{-1}A$-algebras whose kernel has square zero. Hence by definition we obtain a map $(S^{-1}B)' \to S^{-1}B'$ compatible with the maps towards $S^{-1}B$. Consider any commutative diagram

\[ \xymatrix{ B \ar[r] & S^{-1}B \ar[r] & D/I \\ A \ar[r] \ar[u] & S^{-1}A \ar[r] \ar[u] & D \ar[u] } \]

where $I \subset D$ is an ideal of square zero. Since $B'$ is the universal first order thickening of $B$ over $A$ we obtain an $A$-algebra map $B' \to D$. But it is clear that the image of $S$ in $D$ is mapped to invertible elements of $D$, and hence we obtain a compatible map $S^{-1}B' \to D$. Applying this to $D = (S^{-1}B)'$ we see that we get a map $S^{-1}B' \to (S^{-1}B)'$. We omit the verification that this map is inverse to the map described above.

With notation and assumptions as in (2). Let $(S^{-1}B)' \to S^{-1}B$ be the universal first order thickening of $S^{-1}B$ over $A$. Note that $(S')^{-1}B' \to S^{-1}B$ is a surjection of $A$-algebras whose kernel has square zero. Hence by definition we obtain a map $(S^{-1}B)' \to (S')^{-1}B'$ compatible with the maps towards $S^{-1}B$. Consider any commutative diagram

\[ \xymatrix{ B \ar[r] & S^{-1}B \ar[r] & D/I \\ A \ar[r] \ar[u] & A \ar[r] \ar[u] & D \ar[u] } \]

where $I \subset D$ is an ideal of square zero. Since $B'$ is the universal first order thickening of $B$ over $A$ we obtain an $A$-algebra map $B' \to D$. But it is clear that the image of $S'$ in $D$ is mapped to invertible elements of $D$, and hence we obtain a compatible map $(S')^{-1}B' \to D$. Applying this to $D = (S^{-1}B)'$ we see that we get a map $(S')^{-1}B' \to (S^{-1}B)'$. We omit the verification that this map is inverse to the map described above.
$\square$

Lemma 10.145.5. Let $R \to A \to B$ be ring maps. Assume $A \to B$ formally unramified. Let $B' \to B$ be the universal first order thickening of $B$ over $A$. Then $B'$ is formally unramified over $A$, and the canonical map $\Omega _{A/R} \otimes _ A B \to \Omega _{B'/R} \otimes _{B'} B$ is an isomorphism.

**Proof.**
We are going to use the construction of $B'$ from the proof of Lemma 10.145.1 although in principle it should be possible to deduce these results formally from the definition. Namely, we choose a presentation $B = P/J$, where $P = A[x_ i]$ is a polynomial ring over $A$. Next, we choose elements $f_ i \in J$ such that $\text{d}f_ i = \text{d}x_ i \otimes 1$ in $\Omega _{P/A} \otimes _ P B$. Having made these choices we have $B' = P/J'$ with $J' = (f_ i) + J^2$, see proof of Lemma 10.145.1.

Consider the canonical exact sequence

\[ J'/(J')^2 \to \Omega _{P/A} \otimes _ P B' \to \Omega _{B'/A} \to 0 \]

see Lemma 10.130.9. By construction the classes of the $f_ i \in J'$ map to elements of the module $\Omega _{P/A} \otimes _ P B'$ which generate it modulo $J'/J^2$ by construction. Since $J'/J^2$ is a nilpotent ideal, we see that these elements generate the module altogether (by Nakayama's Lemma 10.19.1). This proves that $\Omega _{B'/A} = 0$ and hence that $B'$ is formally unramified over $A$, see Lemma 10.144.2.

Since $P$ is a polynomial ring over $A$ we have $\Omega _{P/R} = \Omega _{A/R} \otimes _ A P \oplus \bigoplus P\text{d}x_ i$. We are going to use this decomposition. Consider the following exact sequence

\[ J'/(J')^2 \to \Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P B' \to \Omega _{B'/R} \to 0 \]

see Lemma 10.130.9. We may tensor this with $B$ and obtain the exact sequence

\[ J'/(J')^2 \otimes _{B'} B \to \Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P B \to \Omega _{B'/R} \otimes _{B'} B \to 0 \]

If we remember that $J' = (f_ i) + J^2$ then we see that the first arrow annihilates the submodule $J^2/(J')^2$. In terms of the direct sum decomposition $\Omega _{P/R} \otimes _ P B = \Omega _{A/R} \otimes _ A B \oplus \bigoplus B\text{d}x_ i $ given we see that the submodule $(f_ i)/(J')^2 \otimes _{B'} B$ maps isomorphically onto the summand $\bigoplus B\text{d}x_ i$. Hence what is left of this exact sequence is an isomorphism $\Omega _{A/R} \otimes _ A B \to \Omega _{B'/R} \otimes _{B'} B$ as desired.
$\square$

## Comments (2)

Comment #1149 by Matthieu Romagny on

Comment #1170 by Johan on