97.18 When is a quotient stack algebraic?
In Groupoids in Spaces, Section 78.20 we have defined the quotient stack [U/R] associated to a groupoid (U, R, s, t, c) in algebraic spaces. Note that [U/R] is a stack in groupoids whose diagonal is representable by algebraic spaces (see Bootstrap, Lemma 80.11.5 and Algebraic Stacks, Lemma 94.10.11) and such that there exists an algebraic space U and a 1-morphism (\mathit{Sch}/U)_{fppf} \to [U/R] which is an “fppf surjection” in the sense that it induces a map on presheaves of isomorphism classes of objects which becomes surjective after sheafification. However, it is not the case that [U/R] is an algebraic stack in general. This is not a contradiction with Theorem 97.16.1 as the 1-morphism (\mathit{Sch}/U)_{fppf} \to [U/R] may not be flat and locally of finite presentation.
The easiest way to make examples of non-algebraic quotient stacks is to look at quotients of the form [S/G] where S is a scheme and G is a group scheme over S acting trivially on S. Namely, we will see below (Lemma 97.18.3) that if [S/G] is algebraic, then G \to S has to be flat and locally of finite presentation. An explicit example can be found in Examples, Section 110.53.
Lemma 97.18.1. Let S be a scheme and let B be an algebraic space over S. Let (U, R, s, t, c) be a groupoid in algebraic spaces over B. The quotient stack [U/R] is an algebraic stack if and only if there exists a morphism of algebraic spaces g : U' \to U such that
the composition U' \times _{g, U, t} R \to R \xrightarrow {s} U is a surjection of sheaves, and
the morphisms s', t' : R' \to U' are flat and locally of finite presentation where (U', R', s', t', c') is the restriction of (U, R, s, t, c) via g.
Proof.
First, assume that g : U' \to U satisfies (1) and (2). Property (1) implies that [U'/R'] \to [U/R] is an equivalence, see Groupoids in Spaces, Lemma 78.25.2. By Theorem 97.17.2 the quotient stack [U'/R'] is an algebraic stack. Hence [U/R] is an algebraic stack too, see Algebraic Stacks, Lemma 94.12.4.
Conversely, assume that [U/R] is an algebraic stack. We may choose a scheme W and a surjective smooth 1-morphism
f : (\mathit{Sch}/W)_{fppf} \longrightarrow [U/R].
By the 2-Yoneda lemma (Algebraic Stacks, Section 94.5) this corresponds to an object \xi of [U/R] over W. By the description of [U/R] in Groupoids in Spaces, Lemma 78.24.1 we can find a surjective, flat, locally finitely presented morphism b : U' \to W of schemes such that \xi ' = b^*\xi corresponds to a morphism g : U' \to U. Note that the 1-morphism
f' : (\mathit{Sch}/U')_{fppf} \longrightarrow [U/R].
corresponding to \xi ' is surjective, flat, and locally of finite presentation, see Algebraic Stacks, Lemma 94.10.5. Hence (\mathit{Sch}/U')_{fppf} \times _{[U/R]} (\mathit{Sch}/U')_{fppf} which is represented by the algebraic space
\mathit{Isom}_{[U/R]}(\text{pr}_0^*\xi ', \text{pr}_1^*\xi ') = (U' \times _ S U') \times _{(g \circ \text{pr}_0, g \circ \text{pr}_1), U \times _ S U} R = R'
(see Groupoids in Spaces, Lemma 78.22.1 for the first equality; the second is the definition of restriction) is flat and locally of finite presentation over U' via both s' and t' (by base change, see Algebraic Stacks, Lemma 94.10.6). By this description of R' and by Algebraic Stacks, Lemma 94.16.1 we obtain a canonical fully faithful 1-morphism [U'/R'] \to [U/R]. This 1-morphism is essentially surjective because f' is flat, locally of finite presentation, and surjective (see Stacks, Lemma 8.4.8); another way to prove this is to use Algebraic Stacks, Remark 94.16.3. Finally, we can use Groupoids in Spaces, Lemma 78.25.2 to conclude that the composition U' \times _{g, U, t} R \to R \xrightarrow {s} U is a surjection of sheaves.
\square
Lemma 97.18.2. Let S be a scheme and let B be an algebraic space over S. Let G be a group algebraic space over B. Let X be an algebraic space over B and let a : G \times _ B X \to X be an action of G on X over B. The quotient stack [X/G] is an algebraic stack if and only if there exists a morphism of algebraic spaces \varphi : X' \to X such that
G \times _ B X' \to X, (g, x') \mapsto a(g, \varphi (x')) is a surjection of sheaves, and
the two projections X'' \to X' of the algebraic space X'' given by the rule
T \longmapsto \{ (x'_1, g, x'_2) \in (X' \times _ B G \times _ B X')(T) \mid \varphi (x'_1) = a(g, \varphi (x'_2))\}
are flat and locally of finite presentation.
Proof.
This lemma is a special case of Lemma 97.18.1. Namely, the quotient stack [X/G] is by Groupoids in Spaces, Definition 78.20.1 equal to the quotient stack [X/G \times _ B X] of the groupoid in algebraic spaces (X, G \times _ B X, s, t, c) associated to the group action in Groupoids in Spaces, Lemma 78.15.1. There is one small observation that is needed to get condition (1). Namely, the morphism s : G \times _ B X \to X is the second projection and the morphism t : G \times _ B X \to X is the action morphism a. Hence the morphism h : U' \times _{g, U, t} R \to R \xrightarrow {s} U from Lemma 97.18.1 corresponds to the morphism
X' \times _{\varphi , X, a} (G \times _ B X) \xrightarrow {\text{pr}_1} X
in the current setting. However, because of the symmetry given by the inverse of G this morphism is isomorphic to the morphism
(G \times _ B X) \times _{\text{pr}_1, X, \varphi } X' \xrightarrow {a} X
of the statement of the lemma. Details omitted.
\square
Lemma 97.18.3.slogan Let S be a scheme and let B be an algebraic space over S. Let G be a group algebraic space over B. Endow B with the trivial action of G. Then the quotient stack [B/G] is an algebraic stack if and only if G is flat and locally of finite presentation over B.
Proof.
If G is flat and locally of finite presentation over B, then [B/G] is an algebraic stack by Theorem 97.17.2.
Conversely, assume that [B/G] is an algebraic stack. By Lemma 97.18.2 and because the action is trivial, we see there exists an algebraic space B' and a morphism B' \to B such that (1) B' \to B is a surjection of sheaves and (2) the projections
B' \times _ B G \times _ B B' \to B'
are flat and locally of finite presentation. Note that the base change B' \times _ B G \times _ B B' \to G \times _ B B' of B' \to B is a surjection of sheaves also. Thus it follows from Descent on Spaces, Lemma 74.8.1 that the projection G \times _ B B' \to B' is flat and locally of finite presentation. By (1) we can find an fppf covering \{ B_ i \to B\} such that B_ i \to B factors through B' \to B. Hence G \times _ B B_ i \to B_ i is flat and locally of finite presentation by base change. By Descent on Spaces, Lemmas 74.11.13 and 74.11.10 we conclude that G \to B is flat and locally of finite presentation.
\square
Later we will see that the quotient stack of a smooth S-space by a group algebraic space G is smooth, even when G is not smooth (Morphisms of Stacks, Lemma 101.33.7).
Comments (3)
Comment #7531 by Anonymous on
Comment #7534 by Johan on
Comment #7661 by Stacks Project on